Discussion:
Tim Powers.
(too old to reply)
Titus G
2024-07-02 05:55:06 UTC
Permalink
I think I have had enough of Tim Powers after reading The Anubis Gates.
It began brilliantly and until we ended up in the 17th century, I still
thought it would continue in a similar way but there was far too much
nonsensical physical and magical violence that was gratuitous and
fortuitous being unnecessary for plot nor character attributes.
Tony Nance
2024-07-02 17:47:27 UTC
Permalink
Post by Titus G
I think I have had enough of Tim Powers after reading The Anubis Gates.
It began brilliantly and until we ended up in the 17th century, I still
thought it would continue in a similar way but there was far too much
nonsensical physical and magical violence that was gratuitous and
fortuitous being unnecessary for plot nor character attributes.
Yeah, that's generally considered to be one of his best. If you didn't
get along with it, he may not be for you.

Tony
William Hyde
2024-07-03 23:33:44 UTC
Permalink
Post by Titus G
I think I have had enough of Tim Powers after reading The Anubis Gates.
It began brilliantly and until we ended up in the 17th century, I still
thought it would continue in a similar way but there was far too much
nonsensical physical and magical violence that was gratuitous and
fortuitous being unnecessary for plot nor character attributes.
I can never get enough of Powers ("Earthquake Weather", excepted) though
his more recent work seems a bit toned down, or perhaps that's just me.

For me the best of his novels over the past decade or so are "Hide me
among the graves" and "Medusa's Web".

Powers definitely did have an early tendency to mangle his protagonists.


William Hyde
Titus G
2024-07-04 05:42:23 UTC
Permalink
Post by William Hyde
Post by Titus G
I think I have had enough of Tim Powers after reading The Anubis Gates.
It began brilliantly and until we ended up in the 17th century, I still
thought it would continue in a similar way but there was far too much
nonsensical physical and magical violence that was gratuitous and
fortuitous being unnecessary for plot nor character attributes.
I can never get enough of Powers ("Earthquake Weather", excepted) though
his more recent work seems a bit toned down, or perhaps that's just me.
For me the best of his novels over the past decade or so are "Hide me
among the graves" and "Medusa's Web".
Powers definitely did have an early tendency to mangle his protagonists.
William Hyde
I had been puzzled and fascinated by Last Call enough to get Expiration
Date, (older than a decade), but have never opened it.
William Hyde
2024-07-04 23:29:51 UTC
Permalink
Post by Titus G
Post by William Hyde
Post by Titus G
I think I have had enough of Tim Powers after reading The Anubis Gates.
It began brilliantly and until we ended up in the 17th century, I still
thought it would continue in a similar way but there was far too much
nonsensical physical and magical violence that was gratuitous and
fortuitous being unnecessary for plot nor character attributes.
I can never get enough of Powers ("Earthquake Weather", excepted) though
his more recent work seems a bit toned down, or perhaps that's just me.
For me the best of his novels over the past decade or so are "Hide me
among the graves" and "Medusa's Web".
Powers definitely did have an early tendency to mangle his protagonists.
William Hyde
I had been puzzled and fascinated by Last Call enough to get Expiration
Date, (older than a decade), but have never opened it.
For what it is worth I found Expiration date to be an easier read than
Last Call, and just as good. Or almost. Why I didn't like the third
book I just don't know.

William Hyde
David Duffy
2024-07-05 03:57:18 UTC
Permalink
Post by William Hyde
Post by Titus G
Post by William Hyde
Post by Titus G
I think I have had enough of Tim Powers after reading The Anubis Gates.
It began brilliantly and until we ended up in the 17th century, I still
thought it would continue in a similar way but there was far too much
nonsensical physical and magical violence that was gratuitous and
fortuitous being unnecessary for plot nor character attributes.
I can never get enough of Powers ("Earthquake Weather", excepted) though
his more recent work seems a bit toned down, or perhaps that's just me.
For me the best of his novels over the past decade or so are "Hide me
among the graves" and "Medusa's Web".
Powers definitely did have an early tendency to mangle his protagonists.
William Hyde
I had been puzzled and fascinated by Last Call enough to get Expiration
Date, (older than a decade), but have never opened it.
For what it is worth I found Expiration date to be an easier read than
Last Call, and just as good. Or almost. Why I didn't like the third
book I just don't know.
William Hyde
I like all of Powers, but maybe it's hard avoiding "nonsensical physical and
magical violence". I like _Dinner at Deviant's Palace_, which ISTR others
find weaker - a post-apocalpytic LA where our hero is riding into town
on his horse-drawn Chevy (but it's just the body on a wooden wagon with
bead curtains instead of doors ;)).

Cheers, David Duffy.
Tony Nance
2024-07-08 19:58:58 UTC
Permalink
Post by William Hyde
Post by Titus G
I think I have had enough of Tim Powers after reading The Anubis Gates.
It began brilliantly and until we ended up in the 17th century, I still
thought it would continue in a similar way but there was far too much
nonsensical physical and magical violence that was gratuitous and
fortuitous being unnecessary for plot nor character attributes.
I can never get enough of Powers ("Earthquake Weather", excepted) though
his more recent work seems a bit toned down, or perhaps that's just me.
I agree. More specifically, I would describe the first two Vickery &
Castine books that way, and -- mostly independent of the description --
I'm not sure if I'll read the third.

Tony
Post by William Hyde
For me the best of his novels over the past decade or so are "Hide me
among the graves" and "Medusa's Web".
Powers definitely did have an early tendency to mangle his protagonists.
William Hyde
William Hyde
2024-07-08 22:47:57 UTC
Permalink
Post by Tony Nance
Post by William Hyde
Post by Titus G
I think I have had enough of Tim Powers after reading The Anubis Gates.
It began brilliantly and until we ended up in the 17th century, I still
thought it would continue in a similar way but there was far too much
nonsensical physical and magical violence that was gratuitous and
fortuitous being unnecessary for plot nor character attributes.
I can never get enough of Powers ("Earthquake Weather", excepted)
though his more recent work seems a bit toned down, or perhaps that's
just me.
I agree. More specifically, I would describe the first two Vickery &
Castine books that way, and -- mostly independent of the description --
I'm not sure if I'll read the third.
I enjoyed the third a little more. I will buy a fourth, but then I feel
that Powers at his worst is still pretty good.

William Hyde
Titus G
2024-07-10 04:35:24 UTC
Permalink
Post by William Hyde
Post by Tony Nance
Post by William Hyde
Post by Titus G
I think I have had enough of Tim Powers after reading The Anubis Gates.
It began brilliantly and until we ended up in the 17th century, I still
thought it would continue in a similar way but there was far too much
nonsensical physical and magical violence that was gratuitous and
fortuitous being unnecessary for plot nor character attributes.
I can never get enough of Powers ("Earthquake Weather", excepted)
though his more recent work seems a bit toned down, or perhaps that's
just me.
I agree. More specifically, I would describe the first two Vickery &
Castine books that way, and -- mostly independent of the description
-- I'm not sure if I'll read the third.
I enjoyed the third a little more. I will buy a fourth, but then I feel
that Powers at his worst is still pretty good.
William Hyde
Given all the positive comments, I will try Expiration Date, thank you.
Jaimie Vandenbergh
2024-07-05 10:44:52 UTC
Permalink
Post by Titus G
I think I have had enough of Tim Powers after reading The Anubis Gates.
It began brilliantly and until we ended up in the 17th century, I still
thought it would continue in a similar way but there was far too much
nonsensical physical and magical violence that was gratuitous and
fortuitous being unnecessary for plot nor character attributes.
The Stress Of Her Regard does at least get the messiest piece of
violence out of the way in the opening pages...

Cheers - Jaimie
--
People who think they know everything really annoy those of us who know we don't
-- Bjarne Stroustrup
Loading...