Post by MoriartyPost by Lynn McGuire"The 10 Best Completed SF and Fantasy Series (According to Me)" by Drew
McCaffrey
https://www.tor.com/2018/09/25/the-10-best-completed-sf-and-fantasy-series-according-to-me/
Wow, I have only read two of these, the Harry Potter and the Ender
series
10 The David Farland series. Read the first one, can't remember
much about it, and never bothered with the sequels.
Come *again* ?
This obviously isn't a list by someone completely addicted to the new,
or LOTR wouldn't be on it, but, um, can anyone who's read these
explain to me how this trumps, for example, um, hmmm...
OK, maybe his logic is that it's hard to know when something is
completed. Most of the examples I want to name have had very
belated sequels, some by other hands - Harold Shea, Earthsea,
Foundation ... But still, this is just bizarre. It'd be like me
naming, oh, Darwath. (Except that's had belated sequels *too*.)
"Farland" is apparently still living. The latest book apparently
came out in 2015. The lister's faith that there won't be any
more is, um, touching.
Would The Dark Is Rising trump "Farland"? That, at least, hasn't had
any sequels, though Cooper is still living too.
Post by Moriarty9 Harry Potter. Read them, loved them and recently re-read the
entire series back to back.
Read, watched all the movies, haven't re-read since to verify my
impression that the movies *haven't* wrecked my images from the books.
Post by Moriarty8 Never read it, but I've been meaning to give Brandon Sanderson a try.
Haven't read any of his series yet, but have been meaning to try.
That said, which series is meant to be "completed", according to
our lister? English Wikipedia doesn't seem to know of any - the page
is *bedizened* with "forthcoming" and the like..
Post by Moriarty7 LOTR. Read for the first time aged 9 and have re-read multiple
times since. Probably time for another dip.
I might've been older than that, but not much older. Re-read most of
what I recognise as Tolkien oh, several years ago, but in my current
book log, and I think again more recently.
Post by Moriarty6 Ender's Game and sequels. The first two were great, the third
mediocre, and the fourth so mind-numbingly BAD that I've never
touched OSC since.
The series <Ender's Game>, <Speaker for the Dead>, "Gloriously Bright"
is good. I'd prefer not to be reminded of the three-book version of
that, and haven't been tempted to read further.
Wikipedia lists three forthcoming Ender books. What, pray tell, is
the standard here for "completed"? I naively assumed it meant
"completed", but that doesn't seem to be the case.
Post by Moriarty5 Never heard of it.
?
Post by Moriarty4 Stephen Donaldson's Gap series. No, just no. I loved all three
Covenant series and Mordant's Need, but the first Gap book sucked
so badly I never picked up another.
I loved the first Covenant series and Mordant's Need, and suspect the
second Covenant series isn't as problematic as I think it is, but
have never assembled the third, and never even tackled the Gap during
the years I owned it.
Post by Moriarty3 Gene Wolfe's Book of the New Sun. I think this is a polarising
one: love it or don't. I got about halfway through the second one,
realised I no longer had any idea what was supposed to be going on
and didn't care. Yes, he's a master of language but I insist on a
semi-coherent plot. I haven't ever tried Dhalgren or Finnegans Wake
for similar reasons.
The plot is coherent, it just isn't even remotely obvious to someone
reading it for the first time.
I've never tried Joyce, but respected <Dhalgren> without loving it, a
lot. The Book of the New Sun, I loved. I used to own first editions
of at least one, maybe two. Sigh.
Post by Moriarty2 The Black Company. I enjoyed the first three. I'll probably get
around to more one of these years.
I didn't like the first one, IIRC.
Wikipedia, citing a 2006 interview, says a book exists which has
never been published, but presumably still could be.
Post by Moriarty1 The Flat Tire of Time. Started out well, peaked at book 5, had a
CMOA to finish book 6, and then just meandered along with the
author having no intention of finishing it. I got up to (I think)
book 9 and meant to pick it up again when/if the series finished,
as I wanted to see how it finished. But I never got around to it.
Naively, there shouldn't be much for me to reconstruct for my book
log from the theft of my first laptop in November 2012; after all,
I have everything up to August 2012, so that's just three months,
right?
The difficulty is that I actually forked my log in December 2011,
when I got the laptop. After that, things I read at home got logged
in subsidiary files at home, but things I read elsewhere got logged
in the main log files on the laptop.
What makes this difficulty overcomable is that just about all my bus
reading and such, for that year, was the first seven or so volumes of
The Wheel of Time.
So although I had mixed feelings as I read, I've had *very* fond
feelings about that series ever since the theft. It's the gigantic
doorstop that keeps the reconstruction door from closing.
Joe Bernstein
--
Joe Bernstein <***@gmail.com>